Dec 07, 2018 · 2. Purraise. 1. Hi everyone, I’m new to community and wanted some insight before I head to the vet this weekend. I’m worried sick about my cat. I have a domestic shorthair who is 1.5 years old. Last week I noticed one of her eyes was reflective all the time. Both of her eyes reflect in the light but one of them does so even in normal lighting.